Skip to content

Tide vs Arm & Hammer: Which Laundry Detergent Reigns Supreme

Tide vs Arm & Hammer

When choosing laundry detergent, you must make the right choice to get the best results. It is no surprise that whoever is reading this article has narrowed their choices down to Tide and Arm & Hammer, as these two brands are known for manufacturing high-quality products.

Tide is the top-selling detergent in the United States because it is known to provide the best results. It is tough on stains but gentle on fabrics and will leave your clothes looking clean. This brand was launched in 1946 and has been manufacturing high-quality laundry detergents since then.

Arm & Hammer was launched in 1846 (176 years ago) and is a brand that manufactures baking soda-based consumer products. They started to produce other products in the 1970s using baking soda as a deodorizing ingredient. Some of these products include toothpaste, deodorant, and laundry detergent.

Some Tide products are more expensive than some Arm & Hammer products. For example, the Arm & Hammer Clean Burst (75 Floz) costs about $4.99 on Amazon and Walmart, while the Tide HE Turbo Clean (100 Floz) costs $11.97 on Walmart. Also, tested reports claim that Tide removes stains better than Arm & Hammer.

DescriptionTideArm & Hammer
Brand ownerTide is owned by P&G and is under their fabric and home care division, their largest unit.Arm & Hammer is owned and marketed by Church & Dwight.
SizesTide laundry detergents come in different sizes ranging from 40 Fl oz to 100 Fl oz.Arm & Hammer laundry detergents also come in different sizes; you can purchase a 62.5 oz or 210 oz.
ScentsTide laundry detergents come in six different fragrances: botanical rain, honey lavender, and the original scent.The Arm & Hammer plus OxiClean liquid laundry detergent comes in a fresh scent.
Cleaning powerTide laundry products have a high cleaning ability. They are known to remove stains more easily than Arm & Hammer.Arm & Hammer laundry products do a perfect job of fighting stains while protecting your fabric. It is also an excellent option for getting rid of odors.
ChemicalsTide laundry detergent is toxic, but it does not contain oxygen bleach, making them an excellent choice for colored fabrics. They do not have fragrances or dyes, so they are perfect for people with sensitive skin.Arm & Hammer laundry detergents are free from chemicals like phosphates, dyes, brighteners, enzymes, added preservatives, etc.
Variety of productsTide has over forty different detergents for customers, which will serve their everyday laundry needs.Arm & Hammer has about six different laundry detergents for various purposes.
Products distributionYou can purchase any of Tide’s laundry detergents in local supermarkets, Amazon, and big-box stores such as Walmart.You can buy any Arm & Hammer product in supermarkets, online stores like Amazon, and big-box stores like Walmart.

Differences between Tide and Arm & Hammer Laundry Detergent


As written above, Tide has over forty detergents to choose from, while Arm & Hammer has about six. Tide has the upper hand in this section due to its expansive product line in the laundry detergent spectrum.

Tide Products

They offer products specially designed to cover your everyday laundry need, such as heavy-duty stains, hypoallergenic, odor defense, cold water washes, etc. They have about ten laundry packs, five powder detergents, and 30 liquid detergents.

These products are but are not limited to fabric sprays, washing machine cleaners, liquid laundry detergents, laundry boosters, etc.

Tide 10x Heavy Duty

It has an innovative liquid detergent technology that cleans hidden dirt by getting in between the fibers. Lastly, it has ten concentrated cleaning actives compatible with all washing machines. Professionals mainly use this product to get rid of tough stains and handle crazy laundry problems, hence, the name.

Arm & Hammer Products

Arm & Hammer Plus OxiClean Stain Fighters

This product is designed to get rid of stubborn stains using the OxiClean stain removal technology. It is compatible with standard and high-efficiency washing machines and will leave your laundry smelling and feeling fresh.

Arm & Hammer Sensitive Skin

This is a free and clear laundry detergent perfect for sensitive skin and free from dyes and perfumes. It is hypoallergenic and comes with the baking soda freshness.


Another difference between both options is their ingredients; each product is made with different ingredients. For example, the Arm & Hammer Plus OxiClean Meadow HE liquid laundry detergent comprises Arm & Hammer baking soda, biodegradable surfactants(nonionic and anionic), and perfumes.

On the other hand, Tide is made using surfactant molecules and has two components (anti-water and water-friendly). It also contains fluorescent whitening agents for brightening clothes, fragrances for fresh scents, and enzymes to remove tough stains.

The Tide Free for Sensitive Skin contains sodium hydroxide, ethanol, monoethanolamine, etc. To know more about the ingredients of each product, check the brand website or the packaging for a complete list.


When it comes to performance, the major question asked is which laundry detergent (Tide or Arm & Hammer) does a better job of cleaning fabrics. So far, we can tell that both options have a high cleaning ability, but Tide is said to get rid of stains better while Arm & Hammer, eliminating odors.

Tide detergents are made using four major ingredients. Fragrances which are used to improve the sent of the products (there are fragrance-free options), surfactants which serve as cleaning agents, whitening agents which help to brighten fabrics, and enzymes.

Arm & Hammer detergents are known for being able to get rid of odors from clothes while keeping them fresh. It is the number one baking soda brand in America and trusted to give the best results. Reviews state that the detergents have a pleasant scent and leave clothes a lot cleaner than before.


Once you are done reading this article, you should be able to tell which the best laundry detergent is for you, Tide or Arm & Hammer. Remember to go through all of the differences completely; this way, you will be able to tell which suits your taste best.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *